User Votes by Image

The following histograms summarize the collected user answers for images which participated in the study. Click on the image name below the figures to see the original image and its retargeting results.

  • Analysis images - user votes on the 37 images selected for the anlysis in the paper
  • All Data - some extra images and data

Analysis images

The following figures were calculated over fully completed experiments on the 37 images selected for the analysis in the paper. For each image, the histogram shows the number of times each result was favored over some other result. Our balanced experiment design used 7 judges, each result was shown to each judge 3 times exactly, and 3 fully completed experiments were collected for each image. The maximal number of possible votes for a result is the total number of times it was shown, which is therefore 7x3x3=63. I.e. a result which collected 63 votes was preferred over any other result by all users. The maximal score was 57 achieved by CR for the DKNYgirl image.


ArtRoom

BedRoom

Brasserie_L_Aficion

DKNYgirl

Deck

Fatem

Johanneskirche

Lotus

Marblehead_Mass

Perissa_Santorini

Sanfrancisco

SetAngle

Umdan

Unazukin

Woman

bicycle2

brick_house

buddha

butterfly

car1

car

child

face

family

foliage

getty

girls

glasses

greek_wine

jon

mnm

obama

painting2

surfers

tajmahal

tower

volleyball

All user study images

The following figures were calculated over fully completed experiments on all images on which we have collected data. The y axis corresponds to the percentage of votes relative to the total number of times each result was shown on screen.


ArtRoom(0.75)

BedRoom(0.75)

Brasserie_L_Aficion(0.50)

DKNYgirl(0.50)

Deck(0.50)

Fatem(0.75)

Johanneskirche(0.75)

Lotus(0.50)

Marblehead_Mass(0.50)

Perissa_Santorini(0.50)

Sanfrancisco(0.75)

SetAngle(0.50)

Umdan(0.50)

Unazukin(0.75)

Woman(0.75)

bicycle2(0.75)

blueman(0.75)

brick_house(0.75)

buddha(0.75)

butterfly(0.50)

butterfly(1.25)

car1(0.75)

car(0.75)

child(0.75)

colosseum(0.50)

face(0.75)

family(0.50)

foliage(0.75)

getty(0.75)

girls(0.75)

glasses(0.50)

greek_wine(0.50)

house(0.75)

islands(1.25)

jon(0.50)

mnm(0.75)

mochizuki(1.25)

money(0.75)

obama(0.75)

painting2(0.75)

pencils(0.75)

pigeons(0.50)

soccer(1.25)

stair(0.50)

surfer(1.25)

surfers(0.75)

tajmahal(0.50)

tower(0.75)

twobirds(0.50)

volleyball(0.75)