NameOSOne-linerFreeform Text EntryFTE MechanismCaptureCapture MechanismSearchSearch MechanismVisual PresentationReminder MechanismListHierarchyTaggingTimeMiscellaneous

E-mailAllUse the inbox as a list keeper1HTML email lets you do just about anythingdne3Have to search through sent mailA full inbox and/or email flagsxxxx

Notepad / MSWordAllBasic text editor1Just typedne3Ctrl-FWYSIWYGxxThe straw man

todo.txtAllUse the command line1Use scriptdne1Command line for itPlaintextxxx

BackpackFirefoxList / Todo manager1Lots of different types of structured text entrydne2Full-textList of listsCan add to calendarxx

Firefox Scrapbook PluginFirefoxCapture web page snippits with right click3Explicitly create new folder, tell it's a text snippit1Right-click and save1Search box in sidebarTreelistxxxMainly for capture; editing of scraps is possible but difficult. Can annotate (e.g., highlight) stuff if desired.

GNotebookFirefoxCapture/notetaking2Firefox chrome button1Right-click1...it's Google. It has search.List of saved notes that is sortable; can share by collection urlnot applicablexx

Hunter GathererFirefoxCapture elements of a web page, by reference, into a collection.dne12One accumulated web pagexCollection renders as new page. Collections represent latest state of component in web page

ScrapbookFirefoxmakes copies of web pages; adds them to individual "pages"3text as annotation of scrapbook entry1keyboard command or right/cntrl click2by listlist of pages, organized into "scrapbooks" on one side; web page captures on the othernanoxSeems hard to get at URL of original page that's been added to a scrapbook.

MyStickiesFirefoxPost-its for web2Alt-click then annotate2Alt-click then annotate3Hidden on mystickies.comYellow post-itsxxIn-line post-its of web pages

StickisFirefoxPost-it syndication2Create new sticky2It's an annotation program3On web sitexxAllows you to subscribe to "channels" of content so I can see what my friends are stickying

StikkitFirefoxInfo scraps via post-its1Create new sticky via toolbar button1Via toolbar2On web siteCan sort by to-dos, calendars, etcTodo mechanismxxxBest sticky note program I found

Circus Ponies NotebookMacNotebook/journal style note collection with variety of page types.1typing, clipping data, by referencetext entry, drag and drop, alias/reference marker1automatically generated TOC, Index and keyword searchpages style: pages can be formatted for multiple types (lined, grid, plane); can support multiple kinds of data entry: writing , outline, cambridge noteslink to ical for to dosXcan create in TOCnotemplates; multiple export formats http://www.circusponies.com/

DevonNoteMacTask-based document management1Supports RTF1Just drag into the program; it will try to detect a good folder match1Full-textHierarchical foldersxxxUses "AI" to make guesses at good task matches, though the technology does not seem to be a selling point. Claims that integrating bookmarks and notes is really important.

ProteusMacOld Mac program1Diary metaphordne2Full-textDiary pagesxxOld CHI publication

Quicksilver Append-To-FileMacCan append to a text file1Command-space, appenddne1Type

SlipBoxMacsnippet keeper, with ontology buildertypesPuts everything in one place - your central repository

YojimboMacLightweight tagging and smart foldering1Create new snippet and supports variety of snippet types [ bookmarks, web archives, serial numbers, print to pdf directly to yojimbo ]; can encrypt individual entries1Drag + drop files, type in snippets, print to from any application, auto capture of URLs for web pages via function key1By tags or textFile folders and listingsnot applicable - but can flag entries or label them (color associated with label)xxxUses a metaphor where everything is in one place -- your central repository

Lab notebookOfflineIt worked for chemists, it should work for me1Handwriting2Use tapednex

Post-it NotesOfflineWrite small snippits1Just writednedneYellow pieces of paperPut them on the fridge, etc.Organization depends on the physical location. Can simulate any of those organizational schemes via a dedicated enough system

Print it outOfflineUse that HP for something1You can type and then hand-edit1Can print almost anythingdneAs originally, except on paperOrganization depends on the physical location. Can simulate any of those organizational schemes via a dedicated enough system

Alpha JournalWinDiary / Idea Log1Create new journal entrydne2Full-textxxAdd date/time via one-click interaction

CuteReminderWinPost-its with reminder capabilities1Click to create reminder/note/idea, then typedne3Full text search hidden within control centerEditable: Post-it on desktopSmall preview of reminder in cornerDistinction between "notes" and "ideas" -- fully formed and not fully formed. Ideas will reappear on your desktop after 3 days.

enLighter RetrieverWinWeb capture via highlighting2Add a comment bubble via a right-click1Highlight web pages, automatically captures them1Full-text search over captured pagesBasic filter searchx

GDesktop ScratchpadWinPost-its1Click and typednedneEditable: an edit bufferNo save files at all -- just an edit buffer

NetSnippetsWinCut-and-paste from any app2Create new snippet1Drag3TreelistxxxAutomatically generates reports like Hunter Gatherer, but you can basically make a table of contents etc. for a group of links

NoteLens (Bederson)WinFlow interface for notetaking1Ctrl-Ndne1Ctrl-FTreelistxxShortcut-intensive

OneNoteWinComplete notetaking solution1Create new page2Right-click and do a screen capture1Full-textDiary pagesCan create todos and remindersxxxThe most developed iteration on the "notetaking" idea. Supports integration with Outlook, todos, reminders, lists and freeform creation

Secure Notes OrganizerWinDiary program with security features1Diary metaphordne2Full-textDiary pagesxx

YawasWinWeb highlighter3Can comment on highlights1Right-click2Use the search toolHighlight in-line in a web sitex

All numbers are on a 1-3 scale. (1 being "a foremost part of the design", 3 being "possible, but very difficult." "dne" (or "Does Not Exist") means that the action is impossible in the given tool.